A large digital billboard above a road displays an ad for McDonald's

What does ‘amenity’ really mean? New legal opinion shows that councils can object to an outdoor advert based on more than just how it looks

The grounds for objecting to applications for new outdoor digital advertising screens have always been limited – they must focus only on public safety and the amenity of the area. Amenity is an amorphous term which encompasses the look and feel of an area, what buildings and features are already there, and if there is expected to be any impact because of what the ad looks like or any noise it might make (visual and aural amenity). 

In practice this means that more affluent areas where there might be more historic buildings, or architectural, cultural or scenic features can more easily object to advertising infrastructure as it is not seen as in scale or in keeping with these features (as outlined in the Planning Practice Guidance on Advertisements). By contrast, areas in which there is already a lot of advertising, or those that are seen as more industrial or commercial with large buildings and roads, as many more deprived inner city areas are, are seen as fair game for more intrusive ads. Of course these understandings of amenity are very subjective, but what they do is entrench existing inequalities and ideas of what areas are ‘good’ or ‘bad’, where people want to live or not, and how people feel about the areas they live in.

What does national planning guidance say about amenity?

Currently it is not possible to restrict or expand how local authorities regard amenity unless the law is changed through the Town and Country Planning (Control of Advertisements) Regulations (England) 2007. However, there is broader scope for a local planning authority to strengthen restrictions on outdoor advertising based on a wider definition of amenity because amenity is never actually defined in the Act. The regulations only say that amenity “includes” aural and visual amenity (sound and appearance). Using the word “includes” is important as it sets out a list of examples, not a complete definition. This leaves the door open for other factors to be included, too.

The regulations also say that councils can look at “the general characteristics of the locality”. This includes things like whether an area has historic, architectural or cultural interest but it explicitly says that this list does not rule out “any other relevant factors.” Again, this demonstrates that amenity is a wide, flexible concept, not a narrow definition.

Previously the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) advised councils that “Advertisements should be subject to control only in the interests of amenity and public safety, taking account of cumulative impacts.” The relevant paragraph has recently been removed, however, which means that advice for councils on how to deal with planning for outdoor advertising is now only included in the Planning Practice Guidance on Advertisements. This guidance includes a more detailed definition of amenity which hopefully will also be updated to allow councils to take a broader view on how this impacts on local residents and their neighbourhoods.  

A more expansive definition of amenity

Legal advice from Landmark Chambers looks at the definition of amenity in terms of the impact of outdoor advertising in neighbourhoods. The advice shows that amenity is a broad term encompassing “the pleasantness of the neighbourhood”, which covers matters beyond aural and visual impacts, such as pride of place, commercialisation, wellbeing, and how the presence of adverts makes local residents feel.

This means that local planning authorities should consider objections to outdoor advertising, or other commercial infrastructure, that go beyond aural and visual amenity, and are entitled to refuse advertising consent on the basis of such objections. 

This is useful as it allows local authorities more scope to decide what is appropriate for their local communities and what helps to create healthy places, or not. Councils can separately introduce policies which restrict specific categories of harmful advertising as many have done.

So what does count as an amenity issue?

The legal opinion demonstrates that amenity has long been understood by the courts as representing “the pleasantness of the neighbourhood.” This is a deliberately broad idea, and it comfortably stretches to cover things like:

  • The outlook and living conditions of nearby residents
  • Adequate and convenient access to services such as healthcare and education
  • Whether a development is unsightly, obtrusive, or involves a jarring new light source
  • How close a structure is to people’s homes.

This means, for example, that an advert that was particularly large or bright so that it interferes with the enjoyment of neighbouring residential properties would be harmful to amenity.

But it doesn’t stop there. More personal, community-level concerns also fit within the amenity definition including:

  • Pride of place – how residents feel about the area they live in
  • Commercialisation of residential areas – turning a quiet street into something that feels more like a shopping area
  • General wellbeing – the emotional and psychological impact of adverts on the people who live there or pass by
  • How adverts make residents feel – both as individuals and as part of a community.

This means, for example, that an advert that impacted on the mental health and wellbeing of residents would be harmful to amenity.

Whether any particular advert actually causes this kind of harm is for the local authority to judge. What counts as harmful on one street might seem appropriate on another, and it must be tailored to the local context. But, councils have a fair degree of discretion to decide what they see as appropriate to that area based on local amenity.

Objections based on a wider understanding of amenity can’t be ignored

Local councillors and residents have regularly raised concerns about the content of advertising sites undermining local businesses and impacting negatively on residents, as well as on the amenity and safety of local areas. Therefore, councils must consider objections to outdoor advertising that go beyond aural and visual amenity and fall within a broader concept of amenity and the impact this has on people. 

If someone raises a concern about pride of place, or about an area becoming over-commercialised, or about the general wellbeing impacts of a digital ad screen, this has to be taken into consideration. Brushing it aside on the basis that it’s not about visual or aural amenity would be a legal error.

If someone raises a concern about pride of place, or about an area becoming over-commercialised, or about the general wellbeing impacts of a digital ad screen, this has to be taken into consideration. Brushing it aside on the basis that it’s not about visual or aural amenity would be a legal error.

And it’s not just that councils can consider these wider issues, they are also entitled to refuse consent on the strength of them, provided the objection is genuinely tied to amenity as the courts understand it. For example, this could also allow local planning authorities to restrict the subject matter, content or design of an advert, where this is genuinely required to protect amenity or ‘public safety’ (Regulation 3(4)).

Importantly, this isn’t about a council simply disliking what an advert says. A council can’t refuse an advert because it disagrees with the message, but it can refuse it if the message or subject matter can be shown to genuinely harm the pleasantness or wellbeing of the neighbourhood. The justification has to be amenity, not taste or opinion.

This means that restricting unhealthy advertising can also be seen as an issue of amenity. However, the direct amenity impacts of the content of adverts is hard to prove unless you can get evidence of the impact it is having on local residents. For example, seeing adverts for fast food, gambling and alcohol may effect people’s feelings about where they live. 

Why this matters

For residents who wish to object to more digital advertising screens, this is a reminder that objections don’t have to be made purely in terms of visual clutter or noise pollution to be legally relevant. Concerns about a neighbourhood’s identity, its residential character, or its general feel are legitimate planning considerations, and must be taken seriously.

For councils, the message is equally clear, including in Local Plans policies that recognise these broader amenity factors are on solid legal footing. And when objections raise pride of place, wellbeing, or commercialisation concerns, these must be addressed.


This post is a plain-language summary of a legal opinion commissioned by Adfree Cities and produced by Landmark Chambers concerning the interpretation of ‘amenity’ under the Advertising Control Regulations and the Town and Country Planning Act 1990. It is intended for general information only and is not legal advice.

Published by