In this guest blog, part of the Bad Publicity series, Greg Fell, president of the Association of Directors of Public Health, examines the role advertising plays in public health outcomes, and, by making comparisons to the fight against tobacco advertising, what we can do to reduce the presence of harmful advertising in our lives.
Advertising influences our choices. Afterall, why would businesses spend so much of their budget on it if it didn’t? It follows then that advertising products that cause harm will drive rates of illness and disease that, without those products, may be prevented.
In fact, initial estimates suggest that health-harming products like alcohol, unhealthy food, gambling products and fossil fuels contribute to between one and two thirds of all deaths from conditions including many cancers, respiratory, heart and liver disease, mental health disorders, and suicide. Moreover, these diseases disproportionately affect people living in the most deprived areas, and often for many years before eventually claiming their lives.
As a Director of Public Health (DPH), I have a responsibility to protect the health and wellbeing of my local community so advertising, along with all the other factors that contribute to illness and disease, is something I – and my peers across the country – need to understand, and address.
This is however no mean feat, with big business spending billions more on marketing and advertising than the entirety of any given public health authority’s budget. So where do we start?
“Introducing advertising restrictions works because it takes a step back from ‘individual responsibility’ and improves our environment, reducing the level of exposure a product is given.”
Fortunately, the progress made over the last 50 years to reduce the harm caused by smoking has given us a masterclass in what works when it comes to tackling these commercial determinants of health (CDOH). Since the introduction of the ban on tobacco advertising, smoking rates, and rates of smoking-related disease and death, have drastically reduced, highlighting how effective restricting advertising can be.
Introducing advertising restrictions works because it takes a step back from “individual responsibility” and improves our environment, reducing the level of exposure a product is given. This lessens the perception of it being acceptable or normal, giving space for other messages to cut through. Far from taking freedom of choice away, it gives us more freedom, taking away the disproportionate influence industry has.
While tobacco is uniquely harmful – killing up to two thirds of its users if used according to manufacturer’s instructions – the lessons we can learn from the impact restricting its advertising has had (and other measures), are invaluable.
With tobacco, central Government played a key role in introducing advertising restrictions. The Association of Directors of Public Health (ADPH) are, alongside a wide range of organisations and alliances, advocating for similar, nationally enforced restrictions to be introduced by the Government on other health-harming products and we were very pleased to see the inclusion of legislation to restrict advertising on junk food in the recent King’s Speech. However, while arguments about nanny statism and freedom of choice are traded by politicians, there is a lot that can be – and is being – done at a local level.

One third of local councils in the UK now have policies which restrict advertising of harmful products on council owned property, or through council owned services. Many of the products and services being restricted are often those targeted at the most vulnerable groups in society, who are generally more at risk from harmful products.
What all these policies have in common is a goal of bringing about a ‘new normal’ in local advertising, controlling exposure where and when possible while at the same time, recognising that a balanced approach is needed so that our towns and cities can continue to attract the best opportunities and bring benefits for residents. Sometimes this will mean having to say no to income, but in so doing, more opportunities are given to promote healthier products and businesses, which ultimately reduce the cost of health-harming products on health and social services. Transport for London’s junk food ad ban, for instance, is estimated to have saved the NHS £200 million since being implemented in 2019.
While local areas are increasingly making the most of these policy levers to restrict advertising, they have no real control over what is advertised on private land or through privately owned services. For restrictions to be most effective, they need to be universally applied and, for that to happen, national policy is needed.
“Restricting advertising is a vital piece of this prevention jigsaw and one which public health authorities across the country are increasingly turning to to fulfil their responsibility of protecting the health and wellbeing of local residents.”
Ultimately of course, advertising restrictions are not a silver bullet and, to truly effectively tackle rates of preventable illness, far-reaching policies that address the availability and affordability, as well as the visibility, of harmful products need to be introduced. Again, this is already happening on a local level, thanks to a wide range of partnerships between Directors of Public Health (DsPH) and other organisations but needs to be adequately resourced and backed by national policy.
Restricting advertising is a vital piece of this prevention jigsaw and one which public health authorities across the country are increasingly turning to to fulfil their responsibility of protecting the health and wellbeing of local residents.
To support this work, and to improve outcomes for the whole population, ADPH is currently involved in two projects focussing on the commercial determinants of health. The first, funded by The Health Foundation, aims to support local public health teams and their partners across all four nations and dependant territories. By making resources that have been developed and used in one area available to DsPH and their teams across the country, no one area is having to come up with the solution. Instead, they can use resources, like Sustain’s Healthier Food Advertising Toolkit, and the CDOH Essentials toolkit, to improve knowledge and understanding of the issues and create tailored solutions for their area.
We are also supporting a major new research project, funded by UK Research and Innovation to investigate how the commercial sector influences public health at the local level in England. By using a systems approach and taking a holistic view of the issues, the research team will identify, implement and evaluate population-level interventions – like introducing advertising restrictions – that are most likely to tackle the negative impact of CDOH and improve health, wellbeing, and equity. The project will also explore and address the barriers to implementing these interventions.
Of course, the overall aim of both these projects, and the work being undertaken at a local level, is to drive down the unacceptably high numbers of people suffering, and dying, from preventable illnesses caused by harmful products. Only by tackling the issue at a population level, can we hope to achieve this goal.
Yes, it requires a bold approach, but there is an array of evidence to show that it can work, and the public health community is ready to work with the new Government to help make healthier, more prosperous communities where people have the freedom to live healthier lives, for longer.
Follow Greg on X (Twitter).
This guest blog is part of the Bad Publicity series, in which experts in fields from public health to surveillance, degrowth and behaviour change explore the ways in which advertising intersects with pressing contemporary social and political issues.
Published by