Screenshot from a Toyota "electrified" advert

Ending misleading car advertising

The UK is moving towards the end of new petrol and diesel car sales. So why are we still advertising them?

Last year saw the introduction of the UK’s Zero Emission Vehicle mandate, under which carmakers must sell a minimum proportion of fully electric vehicles (EVs), steadily increasing year-on-year to 100 percent by 2030. 

The ZEV Mandate will ultimately bring about an end to the sale of petrol and diesel cars in the UK, which is great news. However, what is more ambiguous is the role of hybrid vehicles, those with both a petrol engine and an electric motor or battery, in the phase-out of fossil fueled cars. 

Hybrids still use fossil fuels, still have exhaust pipes and therefore still pollute. And yet many carmakers, notably Toyota, push hybrids as a ‘green’ alternative to traditional petrol and diesel cars. This is reflected in their ads, which frequently promote hybrids using a menagerie of misleading terms to confuse the viewer about the relative benefits and drawbacks of electric vs hybrid vehicles. 

Terms such as “self-charging” used to describe a hybrid draw a false equivalence between hybrids and EVs, whilst the term “electrified” (used by Toyota to refer to their entire range of hybrids and EVs) confuse viewers about the distinctions between hybrids and EVs. Lifecycle carbon emission savings for EVs are 3 to 4 times higher than hybrids when compared to conventional petrol and diesel cars, making them much better for the environment. Misleading ads obscure this distinction, leaving viewers without the right information to make an informed decision. 

Graphic demonstrating the differences between electric and hybrid cars.
Hybrids are not zero emission vehicles, and shouldn’t be advertising as if they are.

The government is now consulting on “phasing out the sale of new petrol and diesel cars from 2030 and Support for the Zero Emission Transition”, which includes amongst other things a question on “What are your views on current measures to support demand for zero emission vehicles? What additional measures could further support the transition?”

Adfree Cities has responded to this consultation to make clear the need to tackle misleading advertising of hybrids vehicles. We first made the case against misleading hybrid advertising in our ElectriLIED campaign last year, which saw us write to the ad regulators the ASA and CMA raising our concerns and calling for action. The ASA responded to say that without government support they are powerless to regulate misleading advertising of hybrids. So this government consultation is the perfect opportunity for us to escalate our concerns. 

You can read our full response to the government regarding demand for zero emission vehicles below:

In previous analysis, we have identified worrying trends in passenger vehicle advertising that spread dis- and misinformation about ZEVs and instead seek to promote hybrid vehicles – most notably from carmakers Toyota, Nissan and Honda, known as electric vehicle laggards and opponents of wider shifts to EVs such as by lobbying against the UK ZEV mandate or speaking publicly against EVs. 

More detail on this issue is contained in our short briefing which can be accessed here https://adfreecities.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/ElectriLIED-briefing-November-2024-V1.2-Adfree-Cities.pdf 

In summary, we identify the use of certain imagery and language in car advertising that exploits popular worries about ZEVs such as range anxiety and uses these fears to dampen demand for ZEVs in favour of hybrids. 

Examples of this include the terms “electrified”, “self-charging” and “best of both worlds”. All of which are designed to sow doubt about the nature of ZEVs and how they work, and the relative benefits and drawbacks of ZEVs vs non-ZEVs. 

We have raised these concerns in dialogue with the Advertising Standards Authority and the Competition and Markets Authority. However, the ASA has informed us that addressing the above issues is outside their remit. Specifically, they are not empowered to dictate to advertisers what language can and cannot be used in car adverts. Only legislation can do this.

To this end, we strongly recommend that the ZEV mandate needs to be matched by legislation to reduce advertising for the most polluting vehicles. We call for a tobacco-style ban on adverts for petrol and diesel cars (including mild and full hybrids). This would help to end confusion for the public about the relative benefits of ZEVs vs non-ZEVs and would clearly signal to carmakers and their advertisers that the era of the ICE is over. 

Published by