Screenshot from a Toyota "electrified" advert

Toyota’s “electrified” ads are greenwash, but unfortunately they work 

Carmaker Toyota is back with more greenwash advertising. This time it’s the UK debut of their “electrified” ads. Long used in the US, Toyota employs the term “electrified” as a coverall term for all cars with an electric motor, be they fully electric or a fossil-fuelled hybrid. 

The problem? Hybrid cars are nothing like electric vehicles (EVs). Hybrid cars (including plug-ins) still have a petrol or diesel engine, meaning they still rely on fossil fuels as a primary source of power. Real world emission tests show that hybrids have very small emissions savings compared to traditional internal combustion engine cars. 

Concerningly, Toyota’s ads are working. A recent survey by New Automotive found 77% of people in the UK think that Toyota’s “electrified” means the advertised car is fully electric when in fact it means hybrid. This makes the term highly likely to mislead and may even result in someone buying a car they otherwise wouldn’t have – an offence under UK consumer law. 

Greenwash works

At the start of this year, Toyota posted record profits off the back of global hybrid car sales. Many in the press crowed over the supposed success of the carmaker’s ‘hybrid strategy’.

What this indicates is that greenwash and misleading marketing work. In reality, the market share of electric vehicles continues to rise in the UK, and other major markets, and other leading carmakers are shifting to electric vehicles, with VW, BMW, Audi and Kia all leaving Toyota in the dirt. 

In its hybrid “success”, Toyota has capitalised on widespread fears about EVs such as battery range and availability of recharging stations, whilst fiddling around the edges with publicity-friendly announcements of new technologies that will never see mass production. (See this hilarious thread of Toyota’s annual “solid state batteries are around the corner” announcements.)

What can we do against greenwash like this?

In 2024, the need to decarbonise the UK’s road transport is urgent, and whilst the solution is to replace private car journeys with public transport and active travel, where cars are necessary EVs are better than fossil fuel vehicles. 

Yet all too often we see confusing and misleading language used in hybrid car advertising that falsely compares hybrids to EVs. This was the subject of our “ElectriLIED” complaint to the ASA and CMA earlier this year, in which we called for tighter regulation of terminology in car adverts. 

The ASA responded to that complaint to say that they can’t be prescriptive about the language advertisers use, only national legislation can do that. Therefore we are writing to ministers to highlight these issues and to push for the legal changes we need to ensure fair and non-misleading advertising of EVs. 

There is nothing preordained about the EV shift. It can stall or reverse depending on external conditions, like the information environment in which people choose their next car. In this light, misleading advertising from the likes of Toyota is hugely worrying as it acts as a brake on greater uptake of EVs, meaning more pollution and greater emissions (not to mention higher car costs) for us all into the future. 

Graphic demonstrating the differences between electric and hybrid cars.
Only battery electric vehicles have no exhaust emissions. Hybrids are still powered by fossil fuels.

High carbon ad bans

Local councils are taking action to clean up air pollution and reduce traffic by removing car advertising. Edinburgh, Sheffield and now The Hague have all banned ads for fossil fuel cars (including hybrids) on ad sites like bus shelters, betting that taking car adverts out of public space will help with the much-needed shift away from private car ownership – or at least away from fossil fuel cars. 

However, this doesn’t go far enough. We need national government to introduce a tobacco-style high carbon ad ban to prohibit adverts for all polluting products (including petrol and diesel cars, fossil fuels, flights, meat and dairy and others) across all media.

You can support our call for a high carbon ad ban by clicking the link below. 

Why would Toyota do this?

Toyota has long been a laggard on the shift to electric vehicles, preferring to double down on the hybrids for which it is more well known (think the Prius). Unfortunately for Toyota, the UK government and the EU have mandated that all new cars sold must be electric by 2035, meaning that Toyota’s hybrid strategy is beginning to look like a lame duck. 

And yet Toyota still churns out PR claiming that hybrids and EVs can co-exist and that EV will only ever make up 30% of the global market. As the world’s biggest carmaker, Toyota does actually have a lot of clout in this area. If they flood the market with hybrids then it will look as though demand leans in that direction, strengthening their case to weaken EV mandates, as they have already done in the UK. 

Published by